When we first visited Mingle2.com, we looked at the pictures they display on their front page. We didn’t like it just starting with that. Most of the pictures are of guys, and not even guys like us. Old guys, guys with kids, even one guy wearing a beer case on his head. Not exactly promising.
But that’s not the main reason. Out of all the emails we sent out, we only got a few replies—sixty, to be exact—and not a single one panned out with a date. That’s not on us, either; we used the same criteria as with our top five sites. While those had high success rates, Mingle2.com resulted in a grand total of nothing. That says a lot about the site, and none of it’s good.
Mingle2.com: Review Our Results Using The Mingle2.com Site
Match gave us results. A lot of results. So did the other sites in our Top Five; the lowest number of replies we got was two hundred and ninety-one. Even that one resulted in twelve dates. Mingle2.com, on the other hand, resulted in sixty replies and no dates during our Mingle2 review. That’s a success rate of 12% on replies and 0% on dates. Really sounds like something you should spend money on, doesn’t it?
Oh wait, no it doesn’t. At least we didn’t have to pay to use Mingle2.com.
Mingle2.com Issues: 3 Things Mingle2.com Didn’t Do Well
Mingle.com has oversaturation of men, which is definitely a problem for straight guys looking to score. Mingle2 scams are also a bit of a problem. Whatever they’re doing to attract people, it’s not working on women. That’s kind of like the guys whose pictures showed up on the front page, actually. Maybe they could try having guys more like us on the front page—average, good-looking guys—to get women to use their site. Instead, they have guys wearing beer case hats right there, “attracting” women to use their service.
Their front page also looks kind of early Internet and didn’t help them with our Mingle2 review. Huge blank sidebars, like they didn’t want to spread out their content more, testimonials right there instead of on their own page, and bright orange text all remind us of the Internet in the 1990s. Speaking of those testimonials, we saw at least one with grammatical errors that can’t possibly convince anyone they have a userbase worth checking out.
Mingle2.com says they have a huge community, and that’s true. We’ll give them that. But their algorithms don’t work so well. We didn’t find anyone who seemed like a very good Match for the profile we created. Sure, we sent out messages anyway; it’s the only way to be fair to the site and how we rank it. But we didn’t get much of anything back not even a Mingle2 scam, and that’s partly because of how they Match people up really doesn’t work out.
Mingle2.com Review: Is Mingle2.com Legit & Worth Joining?
We really couldn’t rank Mingle2.com any higher. They get points for being free, but the fact that we didn’t get a single date out of it kind of indicates why. If they charged us for it, we’d want our money back. Combined with the fact that most of their users seem to be guys, which means our pool of women to contact was pretty limited, we have to knock off any points they earned.
Compare Mingle2.com’s success rate to the sites in our top five, especially Match. Mingle2.com gave us a success rate of 12% replies to our messages; Match gave us 76.4% replies. Mingle2.com gave us 0% dates; Match 4.2% dates of those initial 500 messages and 5.5% of the 344 replies we received. We can’t make you check out Match or one of the other top five sites instead of Mingle2.com, but we will be disappointed that you chose to waste time there instead of picking something that has better odds of working out.